Risks for Bulgarian business after Brexit

Interview with Milena Videnova, Country manager of Coface Bulgaria, at Business Daily, TV Evropa hosted by Dimitar Vuchev.

 


Dimitar Vuchev: It is a pleasure to have you here with us. Now, let’s focus on the analysis on Brexit you presented last week – a topic we have been discussing from a lot of perspectives, but, understandably, with a focus on the Bulgarian business sector, which certainly cannot be ignored in view of everything that is happening now, especially in politics. We already talked about this, before the beginning of the show as well, that United Kinkdom is not our biggest trading partner, yet it is important to highlight the issues that could emerge. What does the situation look like?

Milena Videnova: In general, the big question is whether Brexit will be delayed, as the clock is ticking and the 29 March is approaching. Quite recently, UK’s Finance minister called for a delay, to prevent the country from being plunged into chaos. Companies in the UK in general have been strongly affected by Brexit even before the end of March. Over the last two years, we have been observing a continuous decline in GDP. For 2018 it was 1,3%, the estimates for 2019 are even lower – 1,2%. And for 2017 and 2018, we have a 10% increase in insolvency with regard to companies and 16% with regard to individuals. That is to say, this uncertainty, the depreciation of their currency, is already a fact.

 

DV: Yes, and it was a pretty sharp decline.

MV: It was a fact even before the final decisions in these negotiations were been made. The EU has a strong, firm stance. Michel Barnier is not inclined to compromise, and this raises several different speculations as to what could be done to postpone it, or regarding the probability of going through with Brexit without a deal. This will possibly impact all economies in the world, it will significantly impact the EU, and, of course, Bulgaria indirectly, as part of this ecosystem.

 

DV: So, what would actually happen without a Brexit deal, how will the business sector react to it, with the 29th approaching soon, knocking at the door?

MV: What is most important is the loss of confidence on the part of investors. We are seeing preparation efforts across sectors and segments in this regard, as a final solution. The loss is also associated with further devaluation and a decline in consumer spending. The will definitely result in the introduction of customs tariffs. The employers’ organizations in Bulgaria have already informed the businesses, following instructions from the EU, what a company in trading relations with a partner from the UK should do and what to expect in terms of potential customs tariffs. The entire supply chain will also become obstructed. Some sectors and countries will be more affected than others.

In the EU, such countries are Belgium and the Netherlands, as Britain is their major partner, and Ireland as well, because of the border with Northern Ireland, which has remained a major obstacle during the negotiations. The Scandinavian countries will also be affected, as well as some countries from Eastern Europe such as Poland. As an export and import trading partner, Bulgaria ranks 12th and 18th in the EU, which is why our relationship is not as strong. Some companies are exporting, others are already going bankrupt because of partner-companies from the UK in many sectors, for example in the textile industry and in transport. One thing can be expected without a doubt if no deal is reached: both companies and citizens in the UK will experience rapid changes, and this will also be the case for all of their trading and investment partners. For the time being, the main focus is on the different hypotheses of what can be done. The deadline for the European Parliament is very tight, everybody knows there will be elections in May. The first meeting could potentially be in July.

In other words, changes to Article 50 are highly unlikely in this situation. The other option is voting, holding a referendum, and here the opposing Labour party has an official statement which differs significantly from the opinion of their leader. There has not been much progress in this direction. Support leans toward having one customs union. There needs to be some stability, but in order to achieve it, Parliament needs to be involved, and the Government alone cannot make this decision. Therefore, it would be better to have a soft Brexit, but for the time being nobody is excluding the possibility of a no-deal.

 

DV: All this is very bad for the business, but is there a possibility it will turn into a plus for some countries, or sectors, which can take advantage of the fact that a certain economy is losing part of its investments and moving to other places?

MV: Yes, if they have an active strategy, this is a possibility. One of the most affected sectors will be the automotive sector, and Bulgaria is currently taking initiative and doing everything possible to have the production of Volkswagen located in Bulgaria, which is a billion-euro project. Bulgaria has the necessary conditions, the location is good, we are a NATO member-state, we have good parameters as a member state of the Eurozone, and a sustainable macro- environment for more than a year. That is to say, we meet the criteria of the Eurozone. The other sectors which will be affected are retail, agriculture and manufacture, as well as the construction sector. In terms of opportunity, of course, for us as a country, it is mostly in the automotive segment, because in the other sectors we do not have many foreign investors. There are no big players in the agricultural sector because of the Agricultural Land Conservation Act for foreign companies and persons, so it is mostly Bulgarian companies. But it is possible to develop a strategy for the sectors that will be very affected there, to make a road show. This is what many other countries in the EU will do, of course, and many outside the EU, as well. The question is what Bulgaria’s policy as a country is, how can we take advantage of the investment flow and stimulate it, as it is presently rather low.

 

 

DV: We have been hearing an increasing amount of comments that a new crisis is at hand. This can also be measured by different indicators, of course, and one of them is the number of companies willing to insure themselves against the credit risk, which is potential and real. In light of this, can we say that Bulgarian companies are slightly more worried at this time, and taking action, respectively?

MV: In general, there are two factors and a growing number of companies are realizing that we are in a pre-crisis environment. Either because they are suffering losses or because of the more intensive communication channel, they realize there is no way for Bulgaria to be an exception; a few months ago, for the first time ever, the export for some of our products exceeded the import, which means we fit well in this environment. Moreover, financial literacy is improving, which has been a very slow process over the years. But sooner or later people realize that the expectations are not good, that there will be changes in certain industry regulations, so they think it will be better to insure the receivables and rest easy.

Trading practices are changing, the process is very intensive in two directions – new skills and new markets. By markets I mean platforms and measures and I would like to take the opportunity to say that on 18 April we are organising the Seventh Coface Country Risk conference and this is what our  business sector is interested in. How can Bulgaria fit in this dynamic environment and become part of a winning strategy, even when the environment is unfavourable.

 

DV: Which sector is most likely to be hit by the crisis sooner, forcing the companies to react earlier?

MV: There are always harbingers. One very early global indicator is spending in the automotive sector. In the UK, in the USA and the EU, there is a downturn in this sector, for the first time. This has an impact, of course, on many technologies and on the production, because the cycle there is years ahead. This is one sector that is no longer risk-free. The other sector, which is always affected first, both in positive and negative terms, is transport. Since last year and even before the introduction of changes in regulations regarding workers and maritime cabotage, there was an increase in non-payments. That is to say, we have two export-related sectors, which very clearly give indications, and not only in one region. What is still unaffected, and flourishing, is the pharmacy. Pharmacy and the IT for our region, Central and Eastern Europe. The other sector that will be under pressure, as always, will be the construction industry. I read an article about rental areas yesterday, many properties are on the market already, but their prices have stopped growing, and are even going down. Another factor that is expected to have some influence by the end of the year is the completion of residential sites under construction. It is no accident that the governor of the BNB came up with a clear statement on interest rates, estimating they will start rising from the middle of the year onward. The moment the interest rates for natural persons start rising, mortgage lending will begin to stagnate. So these are some of the sectors indicating a pre-crisis situation.

 

DV: What effect on our companies does the Eurozone factor or Bulgaria’s bid to join the Eurozone have? To what extent the political will to look in this direction affects them at a lower level?

MV: In terms of presence and investment projects, this is a very positive aspect, it is proof that the reforms are happening and advancing. There is a very clear plan, there are due diligence checks from the European Central Bank, happening in accordance with the plan. There is also a lot of advice regarding insolvencies and company resolutions, and the third area includes the judiciary and effectiveness. So, here, for the moment, it is rather the preparation that is happening as planned, regarding the Eurozone’s waiting room, and the advantage of membership itself will be a matter of both results and advancement of the negotiations. But the environment here, in terms of service or production, is quite promising. The biggest challenge is the people, of course, the continuous improvement of their educational level and skills, but at the same time it is the reason people stay or return to Bulgaria, because we are also talking about imports – big associations, linked to shared services centres and the companies there, they already import foreigners, as the quality of life in Bulgaria is quite good compared to the remuneration and the environment, and there are many young people, with good qualifications, who are ready to come and work in Bulgaria.

 

DV: And there are quite a few Bulgarians abroad, as well.

MV: Yes, and there are many Bulgarians abroad who would like to return, so being a country in the EU and more closely integrated in the Eurozone is a good condition for having more people who want to work and live here – Bulgarians and foreigners.

 

DV: At the same time, there is some tension at an EU level – first with regard to politics, and then the economy, where the crisis is expected to strike. It is knocking at the door, as most of the experts say.

MV: Yes, it is. Some of the big economies are already feeling it. For example, Germany, a big country, is experiencing the first symptoms of stagnation. France is also coming up with new proposals such as minimum wage, various other measures and regulations. The European elections will show if (and to what extent) the populists will be supported or remain in the shadow of traditional candidates, because, when it comes to the point, we should say that in the last years, before the integration and after, the quality of life has greatly increased. If we have to be honest, Sofia, as compared to the European Union, is at an average level, and things are much more frightening when you look underneath the surface. The European Union is discussing this, and the outcome depends a lot on how it will be continued in the European Parliament. We’ll know this very soon.

 

DV: This is the political aspect, of course, economics and the cycle of economics, the present moment, the cycle is something that cannot be politically halted.

MV: There is undoubtedly a delay, there are different mechanisms and regulations in use – the Juncker Plan and the various mechanisms of the European Central Bank. The GDP growth is slowing down across the globe, not only in the European Union. There is no way that the European Union can be left out. So, let’s wait for the final discussion and see where our place is among the big countries in the Eurozone.

 

DV: Thank you very much. Our guest today was Milena Videnova, Country manager of Coface Bulgaria.